The Information Commissioner, Christopher Graham, joined a panel of experts to discuss the ‘future of transparency’ at City University London last night. The panel discussed FoI requests, the value of openness, and what happens when the need for transparency meets obstacles such as privatisation or national security.
Joining the Information Commissioner were human rights activist Helen Darbishire, investigative journalist Duncan Campbell, barrister Robin Hopkins and director of Request Inititative, Brendan Montague. The event was chaired by Linda Lewis, course director of City’s Political Journalism MA.
Christopher Graham made his position clear on whether FoI should apply to private companies carrying out public sector work. He said: “Private companies are increasingly taking on public functions. What seems to be so perverse is that there’s all this talk of transparency, but private companies are outside of FoI. We’ve got to find a way of FoI following the public pound. If you’ve got a socking great government contract that is to deliver a service that would have been applicable under FoI, how can you say this doesn’t apply?”
On the importance of transparency, Duncan Campbell said: “The society we live in is built on a fundamental system of checks and balances. There are competing centres of power – judiciary, executive, legislative, press – don’t trust any of them entirely. In order to make the public service function of these centres of power work, you need scrutiny and transparency. It’s the lifeblood of the multi-headed organism that is 21st century democracy.”
Discussion soon moved on to attitudes towards transparency. Brendan Montague said: “There isn’t a conspiracy of secrecy but there is a culture of secrecy in our country. Recently I was speaking to journalists in Norway who can access cabinet ministers’ emails online. Why couldn’t that be the case here?”
Robin Hopkins said that the biggest thing we could fix for FoI requests is the time frames and speed of turnaround. Brendan Montague pointed out that FoI only has power in the way it is used, and that it is the public who bring it to life. He said: “It’s only through our participation as citizens that we increase the power of FoI. It should be an offence to our mind that this information is not being published. We read about political corruption and think ‘of course’, we read that information is being kept private and think ‘of course’. We need to change that in ourselves. We need to get quite cross about this.”
Christopher Graham ended the night with a comment that one way to improve transparency would be to stop cuts to the Information Commissioner’s Office. He said: “Stop cutting the ICO budget. Over the past three years the very modest grant in aid has been cut and cut and cut.”
Dan Douglas | City Journalism | 23rd May 2013
Original article here
See a Storify of Tweets from the panel discussion, curated by Jess Denham (Interactive Journalism MA)
They may provide comfortable accommodation at a reasonable price and broadcast some of the finest repeats on British television but few would consider either Premier Inn or UKTV Gold to be organisations on the cutting edge of educational research. Few that is except Education Secretary Michael Gove.
A Freedom of Information (FoI) request by a retired teacher has left Mr Gove facing a torrent of criticism after it was revealed that he cited PR surveys commissioned by the two companies as evidence of British teenagers’ alleged ignorance of key historical figures and events.
In an article in the Mail on Sunday in March headlined “why I refuse to surrender to militant Marxist teachers hell-bent on destroying our schools” Mr Gove railed against the “enemies of promise” undermining the prospects of young people. Read more
Jonathan Brown | The Independent | 13th May 2013
One in four of the crimes ‘solved’ by Britain’s largest police force last year involved the offender accepting a ‘slap on the wrist’, it emerged last night. Nearly 30,000 cautions were handed to criminals in London for offences including robbery, drug smuggling and even rape.
They made up a quarter of the 118,000 crimes counted as solved by police in the capital during those 12 months. Critics said the public and police are being short-changed by a rampant ‘cautions culture’ which lets off serious criminals.
The figures, revealed by a Freedom of Information request, showed the Metropolitan Police issued 28,998 cautions and youth warnings last year. Read more
Hugo Gye | The Daily Mail | 13th May 2013
Sussex Police fails to answer 15% of all Freedom of Information requests on time. The force, which has come under fire for its failure to answer requests, admitted its own criminality in a Freedom of Information. It said about 140 responses annually – 15% – were delayed.
A spokesman said: “We continually aim for openness and transparency in providing information, and take all such requests seriously. However like most police forces and other public authorities we are facing a considerable increase in FOI requests, both from members of the public and also media organisations, which is stretching our resources.
Warfare may be an awful thing, but it has a habit of accelerating health technology in ways that are helpful to everyone. For example, in World War II the Allies made significant medical advances in vital areas such as developing antibiotic drugs — which the Germans didn’t possess — and performing lifesaving blood transfusions.
Now, however, the military is developing an alarming new interest in the human body and brain. It wants to create armies of mutant soldiers, equipped with unstoppable physical and mental powers.
Within 30 years, according to newly released Ministry of Defence papers, British soldiers should be able to lift huge weights, run at high speeds over extreme distances, have infra-red night vision built into their brains, and even be capable of transmitting thoughts by electronically aided telepathy. Read more
John Naish | The Daily Mail | 30th April 2013
Manchester council is to be investigated over claims they take too long to respond to Freedom of Information requests. Town hall bosses will be monitored by officials from the Wilmslow-based Information Commissioner’s Office this quarter after a ‘significant number of complaints’ were received over their inability to respond within the statutory time limit.
By law, the council has to provide a response to an FOI request within 20 working days. Anybody can submit a request although in certain circumstances officials can refuse to release certain details.
The council will be monitored until June 30 and failure to show signs of improvement within that period may result in enforcement action. Read more
Andrew Stuart | Manchester Evening News | 30th April 2013
YEREVAN (RFE/RL)—President Serzh Sarkisian’s staff has allocated some 500 million drams ($1.2 million) in grants to three dozen non-governmental organizations that have generally avoided publicizing their activities purportedly including human rights advocacy.
The Yerevan-based Center for Freedom of Information has obtained detailed information about the funding, provided from 2010-2012, from the Armenian Finance Ministry. The latter had to make it available in accordance with Armenia’s freedom of information legislation.
Hardly any of the 31 recipients of the presidential grants has been covered by the Armenian media to date. The government data shows that many of them were founded and registered with the Justice Ministry shortly before receiving state funding. Read more
Asbarez Post | 29th April 2013
Michael Gove has been formally asked to explain his department’s “exceptionally poor performance” in stonewalling questions from MPs, amid renewed accusations of a lack of accountability at the heart of the Government’s Education team.
The chairman of the House of Commons’ Procedures Committee, Charles Walker, said he was “well aware of the exceptionally poor performance” of Mr Gove’s team in providing answers to parliamentary questions, and remained “unconvinced” that they were making sufficient efforts in tackling the problem, which has led to increasing claims of a diminished accountability.
With the Information Commissioner’s Office not ruling out legal action to force the Department for Education to improve its record in answering Freedom of Information requests, a senior Whitehall official close to David Cameron told The Independent that Mr Gove’s department was in danger of “resembling an information black hole”. Read more
James Cusick | The Independent | 28th April 2013
With millions in the bank, you would think Tony Blair could comfortably pay his hotel bills. But it has emerged the taxpayer has effectively been subsidising at least some of the former prime minister’s profit-making lecture tours since he left office.
Mr Blair is taking advantage of free accommodation in luxury taxpayer-funded residences on his frequent trips overseas. On a visit to the Philippines, where he was reportedly paid £200,000 a time for two half-hour lectures, he and his entourage were put up free of charge at the UK ambassador’s official residence.
They were able to enjoy a swimming pool, garden and tennis court at the residence, a Freedom of Information request revealed. Similarly secure accommodation in a private hotel would have personally cost thousands of pounds. Asked about such largesse being offered on a money-making trip, the Foreign Office last night suggested such freebies were routinely available to him. Read more
Neil Sears | The Daily Mail | 29th April 2013
Governments made a record number of requests for Google to remove political content in the last half of 2012, the search giant said on Thursday.
The number of official requests for content to be removed jumped 26% in the final six months of 2012 compared to the start of the year, according to the latest Google Transparency Report. Google received 2,285 government requests to remove 24,179 pieces of content – an increase from 1,811 requests to remove 18,070 pieces of content that the company received during the first half of 2012.
Requests were made to pull videos from YouTube, delete blog posts on Google’s Blogger service and to remove items from Google search, making them harder to find. Read more
Dominic Rushe | The Guardian | 25th April 2013
Over 8000 UK drivers are still driving despite having 12 or more points on their licence. The top fourteen licence point holders with 25 points or more are all men.
The official upper limit for license points according to DVLA is 12, or six for those who have held a licence for three years or less. However, a freedom of information request to the DVLA showed many male drivers with 25-36 points were still driving.
A male driver from Warrington has the highest number of points, 36. Currently, there are 20,439,578 male and 16,804,524 female licence holders in the UK, but it’s men who fall foul of the law more often. Read more
Fenland Citizen | 28th April 2013
Europe is on the brink of a landmark ban on the world’s most widely used insecticides, which have increasingly been linked to serious declines in bee numbers. Despite intense secret lobbying by British ministers and chemical companies against the ban, revealed in documents obtained by the Observer, a vote in Brussels on Monday is expected to lead to the suspension of the nerve agents.
Bees and other insects are vital for global food production as they pollinate three-quarters of all crops. The plummeting numbers of pollinators in recent years has been blamed on disease, loss of habitat and, increasingly, the near ubiquitous use of neonicotinoid pesticides.
The prospect of a ban has prompted a fierce behind-the-scenes campaign. In a letter released to the Observer under freedom of information rules, the environment secretary, Owen Paterson, told the chemicals company Syngenta last week that he was “extremely disappointed” by the European commission’s proposed ban. Read more
Damian Carrington | The Observer | 28th April 2013
The Scottish Information Commissioner has found in favour of the Global Alliance Against Industrial Aquaculture (GAAIA) in its appeal against Scottish Ministers following a freedom of information request to reveal information about seals killed under seal killing licences issued by the Ministers, including to which companies licences had been issued and how many seals were actually killed.
Following an investigation, the Commissioner found that the Ministers, while revealing some information, had wrongly withheld information on seal killings and required it to be disclosed.
While the Commissioner did not accept that the retrospective nature of the information would prevent its use by protestors, who might protest about the shooting having taken place, once details were released, she said she was not satisfied that the Ministers had demonstrated that disclosure of the information would, or would be likely to, prejudice substantially public safety. Read more
Fish Update | 26th April 2013
MORE than £100,000 worth of iPads, iPhones and Blackberrys have been given to council staff – despite huge cuts to services in Coventry. Data revealed under the Freedom of Information Act shows top-of-the-range mobile phone and tablet devices worth £113,000 were handed out for the first time last year.
Coventry City Council insists they were purchased at an initial “subsidised price” but admits to shelling out £15,754 on 95 iPads for senior officers and councillors.
It comes when the city council is losing a THIRD of its government funding. Over the next three years, £60million more cuts are expected as well as at least 800 more job losses. Read more
Martin Bagot | Coventry Telegraph | 27th April 2013
Government watchdog Common Cause and 11 environmental groups raised more questions Thursday about the role of gas industry-associated consultants in the state’s environmental impact study of shale gas drilling and fracking.
A review of Department of Environmental Conservation documents obtained by Common Cause through Freedom of Information Law requests shows two more firms with memberships in the Independent Oil and Gas Association of New York were contracted for the state’s review.
The review, still incomplete after five years, is to determine whether hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, which involves blasting chemical-laden water deep into the ground, will be allowed in the state. Read more
Associated Press | 25th April 2013
The Alberta Liberals sent letters to the province’s ethics and elections watchdogs Friday calling for investigations into lobbying by a coalition of construction interests that also made campaign donations to the Progressive Conservatives.
In the letters to Ethics Commissioner Neil Wilkinson and acting Chief Electoral Officer Lorie McKee-Jeske, Liberal Leader Raj Sherman said documents released through a Freedom of Information request to the Alberta Federation of Labour raise questions about the connection between political donations and attempts to influence legislation.
The documents, which include a series of emails after the April 2012 election, include a chain of messages from a construction company executive pushing for a meeting with Premier Alison Redford to discuss labour code changes being advocated by the Construction Competitiveness Coalition. Read more
Sarah O’Donnell | Edmonton Journal | 26th April 2013
Campaigners in South Africa have vowed “this fight is not over” after MPs passed widely condemned secrecy laws that could threaten whistleblowers and journalists with jail terms of up to 25 years.
The protection of state information bill, dubbed the “secrecy bill” by its opponents, was passed by 189 votes to 74, with one abstension, in a parliament dominated by the African National Congress (ANC). It is now a formality for President Jacob Zuma to sign it into law.
Freedom of speech activists acknowledge that the bill has been greatly improved and amended during five years of fierce national debate. But they warn that it still contains ambiguities and harsh penalties that could have a “chilling effect” on those seeking to expose official corruption. They intend to challenge the legislation in the highest court in the land. Read more
David Smith | The Guardian | 25th April 2013
Reporters Without Borders urges French President Francois Hollande to raise human rights and freedom of information with his Chinese counterpart, Xi Jinping, during a two-day official visit to China that began yesterday.
Hollande’s visit is the first by a foreign head of state since Xi was installed as China’s president on 14 March.
“While it is clear from the size of the accompanying delegation of French businessmen that trade will be the leading subject of their talks, it is essential that Hollande should keep his promise – announced by government spokesman Najat Vallaud-Belkacem – to raise human rights with Xi, and this should include freedom of information,” Reporters Without Borders said. Read more
Reporters Without Borders | 26th April 2013
The Australian Bureau of Statistics has confirmed that hackers have recently attempted to break through its security systems to get hold of potentially market sensitive information.
While the ABS says none of the attempted attacks were successful, there are growing concerns that intelligence about Australia’s economy is being eyed by either governments or individuals abroad.
News of the hacking attempts comes from a Freedom of Information request by the Australian Financial Review and, according to that, the ABS has been targeted by hackers over the past four years, including at least 11 incidents over seven months in 2012. Read more
Peter Ryan | ABC News | 26th April 2013
OAKLAND, Calif. – The Department of Defence must disclose the names of individuals who studied and taught during the past eight years at a Georgia school that trains foreign military and police officers, a federal judge in California has ruled.
U.S. District Judge Phyllis Hamilton in Oakland rejected the federal government’s argument that identifying trainees and teachers at the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation would violate their privacy and potentially compromise their safety, saying such concerns were outweighed by “the strong public interest in access to this information.”
Hamilton’s ruling, issued Monday, came in a lawsuit brought by two San Francisco members of SOA Watch, a group that has protested for more than two decades outside the training school based at Fort Benning and worked to implicate its graduates in human rights abuses in El Salvador, Colombia, Peru, Guatemala and other Latin American countries. Read more
Associated Press | 24th April 2013
LANSING — Prompted by a high-profile case of an attack on a suburban Detroit family, a Michigan lawmaker has introduced a bill aimed at limiting the release of 911 recordings requested under the state’s Freedom of Information Act.
Republican Rep. Kurt Heise of Plymouth said he wants to strike a balance between the public’s right to the information and the need for sensitivity, the Lansing State Journal reported.
The bill was prompted by a 2012 attack on the Cipriano family in Farmington Hills, Heise said. Tucker Cipriano is accused of beating his father to death with a baseball bat and trying to kill his mother and brother. Read more
Associated Press | 25th April 2013
Last month the Government banned gagging orders for NHS employees after it emerged that more than £18 million had been spent on silencing 600 staff.
However, the use of similar orders is widespread for departing employees across both local authorities and Whitehall, leading to accusations that ministers are being “hypocritical”.
In Whitehall, more than 200 civil servants and officials have signed compromise agreements in the past two years, at a total cost of £14 million. Officials said it was “standard practice” for them to include confidentiality clauses.
One of the biggest payoffs was made to Philippa Williamson, a former chief executive of the Serious Fraud Office, who left on voluntary redundancy.
She received £462,000 and is thought to have signed a confidentiality agreement.
Local authorities have signed 4,562 compromise agreements with former staff, according to figures released under freedom of information laws. Most of them contain confidentiality clauses. Read more
Steven Swinford | The Telegraph | 2nd April 2013
In Germany, Hamburg’s Commissioner for Data Privacy and Freedom of Information said it will review the way in which Google processes users’ data. Although Google seeks their consent, it is impossible for users to foresee the scope of this consent, Commissioner Johannes Caspar warned in a news release.
Analyses compiled by CNIL raise questions about the legality of Google’s processing of personal data, Caspar said.
The six countries will now take a close look at Google’s compliance with the law. “Should the data protection concerns be confirmed, appropriate supervisory measures may be taken in the individual member states,” he said.
The French National Commission on Computing and Liberty (CNIL) said it has notified Google of the initiation of an inspection procedure.
Peter Sayer | Computer World | 2nd April 2013
The figure will intensify mounting concern over how police can avoid the consequences of incompetence and misconduct, after Sir Norman Bettison, the former West Yorkshire chief constable, was criticised for stepping down while he was facing a disciplinary investigation.
Last week the police watchdog said Sir Norman, 57, would have faced gross misconduct charges and possible dismissal had he not resigned last year, entitled to a pension worth an estimated £87,000 annually.
Chief constables and their deputies will come under the closest scrutiny in the light of the new figures because a record number of senior officers have been sacked or suspended for misconduct in the last two years.
Last week the deputy chief constable of Cleveland police was sacked for gross misconduct.
Figures obtained under the Freedom of Information Act show 1,813 police officers in England and Wales retired or resigned while under investigation for disciplinary offences in the 10 years to 2011, the most recent data available. Read more
David Barrett | The Telegraph | 31st March 2013
The iPad tablet computers, worth tens of thousands of pounds, have been lent to 91 MPs who agreed not to receive information on the committees on paper, according to a Freedom of Information request.
It means that in all more than 250 MPs now have the iPads, because other colleagues choose to claim for tablet computers through the MPs’ expenses system.
Campaigners questioned why the MPs were entitled to iPads when there were cheaper tablet computers on the market.
Matthew Sinclair, Chief Executive of the TaxPayers’ Alliance, said: “It is incumbent on the Commons authorities to demonstrate that money really is being saved by paying for tablets instead of automatically printing out committee documents.
“Otherwise people will suspect that it’s a ruse to allow the MPs to get their hands on the latest gizmo courtesy of the taxpayer.
“In any event, iPads are a top-of-the-range, premium product and there are much cheaper alternatives available which would save even more taxpayers’ money.”
The MPs are all members of one of nine committees which scrutinise the work of central Government on behalf of the House of Commons. Read more
Christopher Hope | Daily Telegraph | 2nd April 2013
City of Edinburgh Council has been heavily criticised for its lack of disclosure of information about a statutory repair scheme.
The council has been accused of overcharging hundreds of city residents for allegedly unnecessary building repair work and expending “a disproportionate amount” of the Information Commissioner’s resources by taking 16 months to release information that should have been disclosed within 20 working days, a report has said.
In October 2011, Edinburgh property owner Helena Wilson asked her local authority for photographs and engineer and surveyor reports, as well as a breakdown of her repair costs.The council insisted that Ms Wilson’s request could prejudice an investigation amid allegations of breach of practice and refused it, the commissioner said.
The council reconsidered and pledged to provide the information in March 2011. But it took another 11 months of pressure by the commissioner to unearth the bulk of the information.
The commissioner has ruled that the council was not entitled to withhold most of the information requested and that it breached freedom of information guidelines. Read more
The Scotsman | 29th March 2013
The Oyo State Government said on Monday that it was not bound to domesticate the Freedom of Information Act.
Mr Ojo Adebayo, the state’s Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice, told the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) in Ibadan that the state’s decision on the Act was guided by the position of the law and not by the selfish interest of the government.
“It is not about the government, but of the law and the law says that both the federal and state government can concurrently legislate on it.
“Being an item on the concurrent list, both of us are free to either legislate on it or not.
“However, while the federal government had legislated and now we have the Act, Oyo State has not done that.
“The law is, therefore, made for the federal government and its agencies all over the country and it is not applicable to us in Oyo State.
“We are not bound by the Act, because we are operating federalism and the state is a co-partner in the federation,” he said.
The Attorney-General added that the state government may, however, voluntarily elect to domesticate the Act.
“Although we are not an appendage of the federal government, we may legislate on it if we feel otherwise,” he said.
NAN recalls that the Freedom of Information Bill was signed into law by President Goodluck Jonathan in May 28, 2011. Read more
Leadership Newspapers Nigeria | 3rd April 2013
The Council of the Isles of Scilly is continuing to ignore some freedom of information queries. And they’ve been issued with their second notice in six months warning that they have breached the Freedom of Information Act.
The Council has refused to explain who gave authority for an official apology to be made in a meeting last May. At the time members were unclear who had authorised the public apology for comments that had allegedly upset an employee during a debate the previous July.
It later emerged that the upset staff member was offered a sum believed to be £500, after they went to a mainland employment tribunal.
The Council refused to say who had signed off the statement, saying it was confidential.
The Information Commissioner has criticised their response for not properly explaining why the information couldn’t be released and for failing to provide an internal review of that decision. Read more
Andy Hargreaves | Scilly Today | 2nd April 2013
Thousands of motorists could have passed their driving test without being able to read English road signs, experts fear.
At least 3,144 learners in Greater Manchester needed translators to guide them through their practical test last year. This was up from 2,274 in 2010/11 and 1,561 the year before.
The figures, obtained under Freedom of Information laws, revealed a growing trend that the Driving Standards Agency (DSA) is looking to ban amid fears that new drivers will not understand basic road signs.
The DSA is also concerned that translators – often a family member or friend – could help the learner to cheat. Since 2009, £94,500 a year has been spent on cases outing such fraudsters. Read more
Mia de Graaf | Manchester Evening News | 2nd April 2013
The FBI has insisted that a formerly secret document about UFOs which became an internet sensation after its release does not prove the existence of aliens.
The so-called Guy Hottel Memo was published in 2011 after a Freedom of Information Act request.
The document dates from 1950 and states that an investigator “for the Air Force” had reported three “flying saucers” had crashed in New Mexico. Read more
Michael Rundell | Huffington Post UK | 3rd April 2013
Children as young as seven are being admitted to hospital with alcohol problems, an investigation has found.
Shocking new figures have revealed dozens of under-10s have been hospitalised suffering from mental and behavioural disorders due to alcohol use.
A Freedom of Information request to all of England’s 166 NHS hospital trusts revealed a total of 380 children aged 10 or under were treated for alcohol intoxication between 2008 and 2012.
Worryingly, 67 of the trusts approached either failed or refused to the Freedom of Information request, meaning the figures are likely to be even higher. Read more
Anna Hodgekiss | Daily Mail | 3rd April 2013
Female prisoners at some of the toughest women only jails have been putting their names on waiting list for copies of Fifty Shades Of Grey after prison chiefs bought copies of the novel, it has been claimed.
According to a Freedom of Information request revealed today, taxpayers’ cash has been spent stocking at least five prison libraries with the ‘mummy porn’.
Now prison sources say the inmates, desperate to read the book, are putting their names on library waiting lists to get hold of it.
The book is stocked at HMP Foston Hall in Derbyshire – a 310-capacity jail, which was previously home to Soham killer Ian Huntley’s partner Maxine Carr
A jail source added: ‘Fifty Shades of Grey has proved massively popular throughout the female prison estate.
‘Women were constantly requesting the book from prison libraries but were told it was not available, so in the end it was decided to get some copies in.’
It comes as Justice Secretary Chris Grayling orders all X-rated films must be removed from jails, but the crackdown does not include books. Read more
Daily Mail | 2nd April 2013
Alaska climate body hasn’t met since 2011, documents show
Rapid-response taskforce – set up by Sarah Palin to protect state from effects of global warming – last met in March 2011
A rapid-response taskforce, intended to protect Alaska from the worst effects of climate change, has failed to meet for two years, according to newly released documents.
The Immediate Action Work Group, which reports directly to Alaska’s governor, Sean Parnell, was charged with developing immediate response plans to future climate disasters.
However, the rapid-response team has not met since March 2011 and its supervisory body, the Sub-Cabinet on Climate Change, has gone even longer without meeting.
Suzanne Goldenberg | The Guardian | 5th February 2013
Information commissioner: Compulsory data protection audits needed
Compulsory data protection audits of councils and the NHS are needed to help eliminate “really stupid basic errors”, the Information Commissioner has said.
Christopher Graham told MPs taxpayers were losing out when public bodies were fined for mistakes in handling sensitive information.
He said “consensual” voluntary audits in some areas had proved a success.
But he said the Department for Communities and Local Government was “surprisingly opposed” to the proposal.
The watchdog currently only has the power to launch compulsory audits across central government. For all other organisations it has to secure consent before an audit can take place. Read more.
BBC | 5th February 2013
Whistleblowing cases reported to the Financial Services Authority have increased by 276 per cent in four years, according to information1 obtained under the Freedom of Information Act by Kroll Advisory Solutions, the global investigations firm.
Kroll found that between June 2011 and May 2012 the FSA received 3,733 contacts to its whistleblowing helpline. This is a 189 per cent increase on the 1,293 calls to the helpline in the same period three years earlier (June 2008-May 2009) and a 276 per cent increase on the 994 calls made in the same period four years earlier (June 2007-May 2008).
Kroll, which provides corporate investigations, says that over the last 12 months almost one in five (18 per cent) of its investigations were prompted by a whistleblower2. In 60 per cent of these investigations the original allegations were upheld, while 19 per cent stemmed from malicious allegations made intentionally to get revenge on an individual or company. Read more.
Claire Middleton | Lawyer Monthly | 30th October 2012
The Information Commission has criticised the Council of the Isles of Scilly for failing to respond to freedom of information requests in the correct way.
The authority was issued with a decision notice on October 4th, forcing them to reply to a request for data on the amount of money spent in legal fees dealing with freedom of information requests.
The request was originally submitted in December 2010 and was acknowledged by the Council in January 2011. But since then, the applicant has heard nothing back from them. They should normally respond within 20 days. Read more.
Scilly Today | 30th October 2012
Last year, 847 credit reports were stolen from agency Experian after a Texas bank was hacked and its account hijacked
In September last year, 847 credit reports on US citizens were stolen from credit reference agency Experian after a bank in Texas was hacked.
According to the Bloomberg news agency, hackers accessed an employee PC at Abilene Telco Federal Credit Union. That PC had access to Experian’s credit reports, so hackers were able to steal the information through a legitimate account.
The breach was one of many revealed following investigations by privacy advocate ‘Dissent Doe’ and other contributors to the DataLossDB.org website. Experian had informed the Attorney General of the breach when it happened, and ‘Dissent Doe’ later found out the details of this breach and more through a Freedom of Information Act request. Read more.
Information Age | 30th October 2012
More than half of Harrow’s public computers out of order
Library users have criticised the council after figures showed that more than half of its public computers are not working.
Harrow Council’s response to a freedom of information request submitted by blogger Paul Boakes, who runs community website iharrow, shows that as of October 19, 76 of the borough’s 142 public computers are out of order.
The worst of Harrow’s 11 libraries to try and use a computer is at Gayton Library in St John’s Road, where just four of the 19 machines are working. Read more
David Hardiman | Harrow Times | 30th October 2012
Council leaders have defended spending millions of pounds of taxpayers’ cash to pay specialist consultants, including a bill of £3.3m to get expert advice on the proposed incinerator in King’s Lynn.
Over the past three years, councils in Norfolk and Suffolk have racked up a bill of more than £13m to employ external experts, a Freedom of Information request has revealed.
Norfolk County Council was the biggest spender on consultants, having spent just under £5.6m in the financial years 2009/10, 2010/11 and 2011/12. Read more.
Dan Grimmer | Eastern Daily Press | 30th October 2012
Sir David Manning, the former UK Ambassador to Washington and a foreign affairs adviser to Tony Blair, met with senior executives at Lockheed Martin and gave advice on the handling of contracts affecting the company before taking a paid role with the defence giant.
Documents released under a Freedom of Information request disclose the contacts Sir David had with the multinational arms manufacturer before he left the diplomatic service and became a non-executive director of the UK wing of Lockheed Martin.
The documents, which were released only after pressure from the Information Commissioner, will raise further concerns about the “revolving door” involving defence companies and senior figures from the public sector. Read more.
Adam Sherwin | The Independent | 28th October 2012
Two pilots fell asleep while in sole charge of passenger planes thousands of feet up in the air.
Their co-pilots had been on the flight deck at the time and both had been alone in the cockpit, the Civil Aviation Authority revealed.
One one occasion, the captain left to use the toilet and then tried to radio his first officer – but got no reply.
He then had to use a code to get back into the cockpit and found his second-in-command slumped over the controls. Read more.
Emma Reynolds | Daily Mail | 29th October 2012.
Stress-related absence has increased by two-thirds over a 12-month period at Gloucestershire Police, according to figures obtained by the BBC.
The number of days lost to stress rose to 4,254 in 2011/12, an increase from 2,586 in the previous year.
Gloucestershire’s Assistant Chief Constable said she was “concerned” by the findings.
The statistics were released under the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act, following a request by the BBC. Read more.
BBC | 29th October 2012
A Welsh council official has said he remains “totally confident” that 2,400 publicly funded laptops worth £1m will find a home soon, despite the expiration of the devices’ warranties nearly nine months ago.
Torfaen County Borough Council, based in south Wales, controversially procured 8,600 laptops in April 2011 from XMA, amid claims from reseller rivals that the process was unfair as the original tender was for the much smaller amount of just 408 devices.
A Freedom of Information request filed by ChannelWeb showed that, of the original 8,600 HP notebooks, 6,200 are finally in use across Torfaen and Monmouthshire as part of the iLearnWales initiative, while the remaining portion gathers dust in storage. Read more.
Hannah Breeze | Channel Web | 29th October 2012
The Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (Ipsa), which oversees expenses payments, has been told it must disclose the receipts handed in by MPs to back up their claims. The ruling by the Information Commissioner is a victory for The Sunday Telegraph, after Ipsa refused to release three receipts we had asked to see.
Graham Smith investigated its refusal and found that the authority had breached the Freedom of Information Act. He gave officials five weeks to hand over the documents or face prosecution for contempt of court. Read more.
Ben Leapman | The Telegraph | 27th October 2012
Scottish Liberal Democrat justice spokesperson Alison McInnes MSP has praised her party’s strong record of action in improving civil liberties and delivering freedom of information legislation in Scotland. Mrs McInnes told Conference delegates that under the SNP government, citizens are seeing their right of access to public information eroded.
In a motion approved by Conference Mrs McInnes raised concern about the SNP Government’s unwillingness to expand freedom of information laws to cover arms length public bodies such as housing associations.
Commenting after the motion was approved, Mrs McInnes MSP said:
“Access to information is important in a free and liberal Scotland to challenge those who wield power. I’m hugely proud of my party for introducing the Freedom of Information Act in 2002, which is now a cornerstone of our modern liberal Scotland. Read more.
ScotLibDems | 27th October 2012
Shameless peers are demanding taxpayers buy them swanky iPads — which could cost up to £380,000.
Lords and ladies — who are often spotted snoozing on the benches — want to follow in the footsteps of MPs who now get the Apple gadgets for free.
Freedom of Information requests revealed the issue was repeatedly raised in responses to a recent House of Lords survey. One peer complained his taxpayer-funded BlackBerry was “awkward”, adding: “Time to go iPad? Read more.
Emily Ashton | The Sun | 27th October 2012
Hundreds of crimes recorded at the University of Hertfordshire shock figures reveal
Rape, robbery and racially aggravated assault are not traditionally part of the three R’s – but all have been reported at The University of Hertfordshire in the past 12 months.
Details of crimes alleged to have been committed at the Hatfield campuses have been released by police – with a hoax bomb threat and drug dealing claims also investigated in the past year.
The Welwyn Hatfield Times obtained details of the offences under the Freedom of Information Act, with 219 crimes probed over the past year, including four sexual offences. Read more.
Ewan Foskett | Welwyn Hatfield Times | 27th October 2012
As often happens, the Federal Bureau of Investigation invoked national security a few years ago to justify withholding certain information from a Freedom of Information Act requester named Deirdre McKiernan Hetzler.
But as rarely happens, a court last month critically assessed the FBI national security claim and ordered the Bureau to release some of the withheld information.
Ms. Hetzler, acting pro se (i.e. without an attorney), had requested records concerning her deceased father, who had once been the subject of an FBI investigation. The FBI provided her with some records but withheld others, stating that they remained classified in order to protect an intelligence activity.
Steven Aftergood | Fas Project on Government Secrecy | 26th October 2012
Public sector bodies will generally be required to disclose information even if it is stored in computer ‘recycle bins’, the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has said. The watchdog has issued new guidance (25-page / 350KB PDF) to help public bodies which are subject to the UK freedom of information (FOI) or environmental information laws to determine whether they hold information that should be disclosed when requested. Under UK FOI laws and the Environmental Information Regulations (EIR)individuals have a right to ask for and, generally, be provided with certain information held by Government departments and public bodies. Read more.
Out Law | 12thOctober 2012
South Australians are drinking water containing potentially carcinogenic compounds, a new report warns. Freedom of Information data from SA Water shows the state’s tap water breached the Australian Drinking Water Guidelines or World Health Organisation guidelines 9298 times between January 2000 and July 2012. While Government authorities say South Australians have nothing to fear, experts say it is unclear whether prolonged exposure would increase the risk of cancer. Read more.
Jordanna Schriever | The Australian | 13thOctober 2012
Nearly 250 thrill seekers were caught with drugs at one of Britain’s top theme parks in the past year. Visitors to Thorpe Park, which attracts millions of families a year, were caught with substances including heroin and cocaine. Freedom of information figures show 234 cases of people discovered with drugs since last October. They included 38 cases of visitors caught with cocaine, 154 with cannabis and 22 with MDMA or amphetamines. Three had ketamine and one heroin. Read more.
Nick Dorman | The People | 14thOctober 2012
Nearly 2,500 teaching days were lost due to stress in North Lincolnshire’s schools over the last academic year. The figures, obtained through the Freedom of Information Act, show a 22 per cent increase in days lost to stress compared to the previous academic year. There was also an increase in the number of days lost by head teachers due to stress – a rise from 19 in the 2010/11 academic year to 355 in the 2011/12 academic year. Read more.
Scunthorpe Telegraph | 13thOctober 2012
A cash-strapped council has recorded a dramatic drop in the amount it spends on business flights. A Freedom of Information Act request revealed that Sunderland City Council spent just £1,613 on domestic work-related fights in the last financial year – a reduction of more than £9,000 over three years. In 2009 to 2010, the travelling expenditure was £10,753, dropping to £4,238 in 2010 to 2011, before reaching the latest figure. Read more.
Sunderland Echo | 12th October 2012